Table of Contents
At this point we’ve gone over the vast majority of the most important topics to eat healthily and work towards a healthy body composition. We’ve discussed metabolism, calories, a strategy for gaining or losing weight if desired and how to track progress when doing so, macronutrients, micronutrients, food groups, the timing of when we eat, various dieting schemes, and how to overcome barriers related to cost and time.
Yet, even knowing all of this there are still additional barriers to long-term success. Many people feel guilty and/or shamed about their perceived “weight problem”, and with a negative mindset it can be really difficult to begin any new journey and build new, healthy habits. On the other end of the dieting journey, most people who are able to lose weight eventually gain it back. In this lesson we’ll discuss these issues in more detail.
Guilt, stigma, and stress associated with obesity
It’s very easy to simply say someone with obesity should eat less, exercise more, and then their obesity will disappear. Problem solved! However, if it was that simple then obesity wouldn’t be so incredibly difficult to treat on a population and individual level, there wouldn’t be so many fad and gimmicky diets, there wouldn’t be such a large supplement industry for weight loss, and there wouldn’t be so many books and literature written on this topic. So why is this something that so many people struggle with while others do not seem to have as much of an issue?
We actually already talked about this to some degree in Lesson 1 when discussing how resting metabolic rate & non-exercise activity thermogenesis can vary between individuals. In addition to this, there seems to be significant appetite/taste differences between people with and without obesity, with differences seen in gene expression of taste buds(Archer, 2019), differences in taste sensation in response to high fat & sugary substances (even prior to the onset of obesity)(Yokum, 2019), differences in hunger & hunger hormone responses to the same meal(Goltz, 2019), and differences in brain reward region responses to palatable food as well as prefrontal region activation that may make overeating more likely.(Hall, 2014) All of this will make people more prone towards eating tasty, calorie-filled foods.
In one review of appetite control it is noted that increased fat-free mass tends to drive increased energy intake (individuals with obesity will generally have more fat-free mass as this helps support the additional fat mass).(MacLean, 2017) The authors here also note that increased fat mass actually seems to inhibit energy intake in individuals with healthy weight, but in individuals with obesity the fat mass does not inhibit energy intake. They also note that decreased insulin sensitivity (commonly seen with obesity) decreases postprandial satiety. This will make people with obesity more prone to eating excess calories.
Additionally, there seems to be a very large genetic influence on obesity and related traits.(Qasim, 2018) One review discussing this notes heritability estimates of 32-49% for variance in energy intake, 20-78% for preference of different food groups, 63% for satiety responsiveness, 75% for food cue responsiveness, and 45-74% for rate of consumption.(Reddon, 2018) There also seems to be a very large interplay between genetic heritability and one’s local environment; one study of twins at age 4 found heritability of BMI was much higher in the higher obesity-risk homes (86%) compared to the lower obesity-risk homes (39%).(Schrempft, 2018) This can manifest if someone with a sweet tooth lives in a home with many sweets available; they will be prone to overeating, but if they were to live in a home without sweets available they would not overeat.
I think this last point is key for explaining a large part of the reason why we have the obesity epidemic in the first place. Over the last several decades there has been an increase in readily available sources of calories(Vandevijvere, 2015), as seen with larger portions sizes, more fast food restaurants, and an ever-expanding array of food choice options. Thus, our entire society has become a higher risk “food environment” for people who are prone to obesity, and those with genetics inclined towards obesity will simply have a more difficult time as a result.
Tip: By getting all of the snack and junk food that you do not wish to eat out of the home it is much easier to avoid it. Many people will have a hard time resisting snacks that are present in the home 24/7. It is generally much less likely for people to develop cravings so strong that they feel the need to run out to a store to purchase snacks. Optimizing your food environment can make it much easier to stick to a healthy eating plan. If you do want to include treats occasionally that is fine to do, but if keeping them in the home is going to prove problematic then consider purchasing small quantities (ie, an individual piece of candy instead of a bag of candy) so you cannot binge on them regularly.
Stigma, guilt, and shame
In addition to the genetic influences, many people with obesity experience weight stigma, which generally makes adopting healthier habits and working on body weight management even more difficult.(Rubino, 2020) This is true not only for adults but also for adolescents as well as children.(Schvey, 2019; Pont, 2017) Stigma even occurs readily in the medical profession.(Ananthakumar, 2020; Puhl, 2020) This is yet another source of stress, and stress itself has been found to worsen obesity and weight management through a variety of mechanisms.(Geiker, 2017) This includes worsening sleep, which generally decreases willpower to resist temptation and can lead to increased caloric consumption. Stress also makes it harder to start a diet or any lifestyle change successfully. Additionally, highly palatable foods can help relieve stress, which can then generate a feedback loop where the brain begins to desire these foods to a greater degree.(Tomiyama, 2019)
Thus, there are many contributing factors to obesity, some of which are out of an individual’s control. By no means does this make it impossible to engage in healthier habits and lose weight, but it does seem like this will be harder for some individuals than others. For these reasons, blaming somebody for their own obesity seems short-sighted, and it may be more appropriate to actually blame the increased food availability in our society as well as the increased technology leading to less physical activity overall. As stigma has generally been shown to be harmful as opposed to helpful, and increasing stress makes any lifestyle change harder, I do not believe there is an evidence-based rationale to attempt to shame people with obesity into losing weight.
Note: I’m sure some people may have read the above and scoffed to some degree, thinking we should be shaming people into losing weight. To be clear, anecdotally there are some people who do not develop any motivation to lose weight until they undergo some sort of shaming experience. So for some people being shamed does seem to spur motivation and lead to positive changes. However, for many people this is not the case, and to my knowledge there is no evidence-based method to determine which subset of people may turn shaming into positive change.
Regardless, while shaming may provide motivation for some people, there are tons of people who do want to make changes and have been unsuccessful in doing so. For this group of people I cannot conceptualize any possible benefit of shaming; they already have the desire to make change but lack the knowledge or means to do so. Further shaming them will not fix those two issues, but it will likely increase stress levels and make things even harder.
Thus, in general, I am not a fan of fat-shaming.
So what should you do if you suffer from guilt, stigma, and stress associated with your weight status? Hopefully the above rationale of the underlying genetic and environmental influences beyond an individual’s control can help alleviate some of the guilt. Additionally, if you develop a plan of action, stick with it, and start seeing results, this should help increase motivation and positive feelings regarding the entire process. Some people will benefit from therapy regarding these topics; if you think this may apply to you consider discussing with your healthcare provider. If there are specific people in your life who are making things difficult attempt to engage them in an honest conversation about how they can be more supportive. Lastly, if you can find a peer or peer group to join you on a journey to a healthier lifestyle that can be very motivating and beneficial.
Habits to aid weight maintenance after weight loss
Many people diet and lose weight to some degree but then ultimately gain it back. In fact, in one systematic review of studies in adults with at least 3 years follow-up after an obesity intervention, all eight of the studies showed significant weight regain with seven showing continually increasing weight at every follow-up time point.(Nordimo, 2020) This is undesirable for several reasons. The obvious ones are that one’s self-esteem may take a hit when progress is lost and any health benefits of getting the extra body fat (“BF”) off may reverse when weight is regained.
However, there are additional reasons as well. If people diet successfully and become relatively lean prior to gaining the weight back it can lead to fat overshoot where the resultant BF percentage becomes higher than it was prior to dieting in the first place.(Jacquet, 2020) Repetitive weight cycling has also been associated with decreased muscle mass and a higher risk of developing sarcopenia.(Rossi, 2019)
Note: The underlying mechanism for fat overshoot seems to come from the concept of “partitioning”, where as weight is lost a certain percentage will be lean body mass (“LBM”) and a certain percentage will be BF. The leaner one becomes the greater the percentage is LBM. When weight is regained, BF increases more quickly than LBM, and thus for the body to reach the prior levels of LBM there has to be “fat overshoot” where the amount of BF regained actually surpasses the amount of BF there was initially. This is one of the reasons I’ve emphasized the importance of resistance training, eating sufficient protein, and losing weight at a reasonable pace, as all of this will help you maintain your LBM while losing fat and thus fat overshooting should be much less likely to occur.
While studies do show that most people gain weight back, there are obviously some people who successfully keep the extra weight off. What separates these individuals from everyone else? There have been many studies evaluating this, some recent ones include a systematic review & meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials implementing behavior change techniques(Ashton, 2020), a study evaluating people who were able to successfully maintain weight loss for five years(Lawlor, 2020), a systematic review of studies of successful weight loss maintainers in weight control registries(Paixão, 2020), as well as analyses in children(van der Heijden, 2018; Jones, 2019).
When reading through this literature a few themes & habits emerge that many successful individuals implement. These include:
- Self-monitoring. This can be done with regular self-weighing, tracking food intake to some degree, paying attention to the way clothes fit, keeping a step counter, or a variety of other methods. Self-monitoring has been found to be very helpful for active weight loss(Harvey, 2019) and avoiding weight gain over the holidays(Kaviani, 2019) in addition to long term weight maintenance after weight loss.
- Goal setting. Setting small, specific, realistic goals and then achieving them can be very motivating and provide evidence that what you are doing is actually working. These goals can work towards larger, long-term goals. Consider setting both “process” goals and “outcome” goals. The former regards building habits (ie, “I will start at least 5 minutes of exercise daily” or “I will not buy any junk food the next time I go to the store”). The latter regards outcomes (ie, “I will lose 2 pounds in the next month” or “the next time my doctor checks my cholesterol levels they will be improved”). For weight maintenance, goals can still be set to maintain your weight, improve your exercise performance, continue your healthy habits, etc.
- Social support. This is very important both in the home and in the social setting. In the home it is difficult to make significant healthy changes (ie, cut out cookies) if everyone else is eating cookies in front of you. If you can get your immediate family to be on the same page and everybody buys in to starting healthier habits together and thus supports each other it can be much easier to be successful. Regarding social settings, when out with people who are understanding and not trying to push unhealthy foods onto you it is much easier than if you are with people who are going to try to throw you off of your healthier habits. There is no need to avoid going out with others but try to ensure the people you are with will be supportive.
- Meal preparation. This was discussed in Lesson 13, but preparing meals in advance and having healthier options you can quickly pack and take with you if you need to eat out will make it much easier to stick with your nutrition goals.
- Distraction strategies. If you are hungry you can consider if you really need to eat now or if there are other things you can do to take your mind off of hunger, such as drinking fluids (as sometimes thirst presents as hunger), walking, reading, etc. Many people find they get hungrier when they are bored; using various distraction strategies will help prevent this from leading you to eating more than you wish. This can also help deal with cravings.
Tip: While distraction strategies are great when they work, at times you may simply be hungry and nothing will work other than eating. In this situation you can consider eating a meal early, but if you really need a snack consider choosing a more filling option. One study developed a “satiety index” for common foods, where foods were ranked by how satiating they were.(Holt, 1995) They tested 38 foods and assigned them a score in reference to white bread (assigned a default score of 100). The 5 most satiating foods were:
- potatoes at 323 (they tested Russet potatoes that were peeled, boiled for 20 minutes, and stored in a refrigerator overnight prior to reheating in a microwave)
- ling fish at 225 (stored frozen, then steamed, stored in a refrigerator overnight, and reheated in a microwave)
- porridge at 209 (made from raw rolled oats cooked in a microwave with reduced fat milk)
- oranges at 202 (fresh, peeled)
- apples at 197 (fresh, skin was included)
While most people are not going to have ling fish laying around their home, the other foods are all reasonable options to prepare in snack-sized quantities and can be good options if hungry. There is likely some individual variability regarding satiety of different foods so consider trying different options and see what works best for you.
Additionally, a recent study suggested that adopting a healthy mindset regarding food options can lead to one naturally selecting smaller portions.(Veit, 2020) While more research needs to be done regarding this, when really hungry consider viewing snacks as a way of giving your body what it needs as opposed to failing with your dietary goals and this may help you not “fall off the wagon” and start binging or engaging in other undesirable behaviors.
- Continued motivation. This is really important after losing weight. When actively losing weight and seeing the results on the scale or in the mirror it can be very motivating to continue pushing forward. After weight loss is complete that initial source of motivation can vanish. Finding some way to continue to stay motivated is critical. This is one of the reasons it is very helpful to adopt healthy lifestyle changes as opposed to following any sort of a crash diet; if you make an actual lifestyle change and it becomes ingrained in your habits then continued motivation is not as necessary if you can continue your new lifestyle indefinitely.
- Physical activity. While not the topic of this course, continued physical activity & exercise is helpful for maintaining weight loss and further improving health.
Thus, there are several strategies that will help aid weight maintenance after weight loss. Most of these strategies are also beneficial for initial weight loss. Building all of this into a healthy lifestyle with support from family and peers that can be carried forward indefinitely is ideal for sustained success.
There are many contributing factors to obesity, several of which are outside of one’s individual control, and thus some people will have a much more difficult time dealing with this than others. The negative stigma regarding obesity in our society and the associated stress make dealing with obesity even more difficult. Nonetheless, adopting a healthier lifestyle and losing weight is not an impossible task, and many people are able to do this successfully. By planning things out and adopting beneficial habits there is usually a path forward to success. Finding the right individual path is imperative; no two people have the same shared set of experiences and thus helpful tricks, triggering situations, and definitions of success will differ between everybody.
- Ananthakumar T, Jones NR, Hinton L, Aveyard P. Clinical encounters about obesity: Systematic review of patients’ perspectives. Clin Obes. 2020 Feb;10(1):e12347. doi: 10.1111/cob.12347. Epub 2019 Dec 2. PMID: 31793217.
- Archer N, Shaw J, Cochet-Broch M, Bunch R, Poelman A, Barendse W, Duesing K. Obesity is associated with altered gene expression in human tastebuds. Int J Obes (Lond). 2019 Jul;43(7):1475-1484. doi: 10.1038/s41366-018-0303-y. Epub 2019 Jan 29. PMID: 30696932.
- Ashton LM, Sharkey T, Whatnall MC, Haslam RL, Bezzina A, Aguiar EJ, Collins CE, Hutchesson MJ. Which behaviour change techniques within interventions to prevent weight gain and/or initiate weight loss improve adiposity outcomes in young adults? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Obes Rev. 2020 Jun;21(6):e13009. doi: 10.1111/obr.13009. Epub 2020 Feb 16. Erratum in: Obes Rev. 2020 Oct;21(10):e13111. PMID: 32064761.
- Geiker NRW, Astrup A, Hjorth MF, Sjödin A, Pijls L, Markus CR. Does stress influence sleep patterns, food intake, weight gain, abdominal obesity and weight loss interventions and vice versa? Obes Rev. 2018 Jan;19(1):81-97. doi: 10.1111/obr.12603. Epub 2017 Aug 28. PMID: 28849612.
- Goltz FR, Thackray AE, Atkinson G, Lolli L, King JA, Dorling JL, Dowejko M, Mastana S, Stensel DJ. True Interindividual Variability Exists in Postprandial Appetite Responses in Healthy Men But Is Not Moderated by the FTO Genotype. J Nutr. 2019 Jul 1;149(7):1159-1169. doi: 10.1093/jn/nxz062. PMID: 31132105; PMCID: PMC6602891.
- Hall KD, Hammond RA, Rahmandad H. Dynamic interplay among homeostatic, hedonic, and cognitive feedback circuits regulating body weight. Am J Public Health. 2014 Jul;104(7):1169-75. doi: 10.2105/AJPH.2014.301931. Epub 2014 May 15. PMID: 24832422; PMCID: PMC4056226.
- Harvey J, Krukowski R, Priest J, West D. Log Often, Lose More: Electronic Dietary Self-Monitoring for Weight Loss. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2019 Mar;27(3):380-384. doi: 10.1002/oby.22382. PMID: 30801989; PMCID: PMC6647027.
- Holt SH, Miller JC, Petocz P, Farmakalidis E. A satiety index of common foods. Eur J Clin Nutr. 1995 Sep;49(9):675-90. PMID: 7498104.
- Jacquet P, Schutz Y, Montani JP, Dulloo A. How dieting might make some fatter: modeling weight cycling toward obesity from a perspective of body composition autoregulation. Int J Obes (Lond). 2020 Jun;44(6):1243-1253. doi: 10.1038/s41366-020-0547-1. Epub 2020 Feb 25. PMID: 32099104; PMCID: PMC7260129.
- Jones HM, Al-Khudairy L, Melendez-Torres GJ, Oyebode O. Viewpoints of adolescents with overweight and obesity attending lifestyle obesity treatment interventions: a qualitative systematic review. Obes Rev. 2019 Jan;20(1):156-169. doi: 10.1111/obr.12771. Epub 2018 Oct 29. PMID: 30375160.
- Kaviani S, vanDellen M, Cooper JA. Daily Self-Weighing to Prevent Holiday-Associated Weight Gain in Adults. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2019 Jun;27(6):908-916. doi: 10.1002/oby.22454. PMID: 31119881.
- Lawlor ER, Hughes CA, Duschinsky R, Pountain GD, Hill AJ, Griffin SJ, Ahern AL. Cognitive and behavioural strategies employed to overcome “lapses” and prevent “relapse” among weight-loss maintainers and regainers: A qualitative study. Clin Obes. 2020 Oct;10(5):e12395. doi: 10.1111/cob.12395. Epub 2020 Aug 7. PMID: 32767708.
- MacLean PS, Blundell JE, Mennella JA, Batterham RL. Biological control of appetite: A daunting complexity. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2017 Mar;25 Suppl 1(Suppl 1):S8-S16. doi: 10.1002/oby.21771. PMID: 28229538; PMCID: PMC5407690.
- Nordmo M, Danielsen YS, Nordmo M. The challenge of keeping it off, a descriptive systematic review of high-quality, follow-up studies of obesity treatments. Obes Rev. 2020 Jan;21(1):e12949. doi: 10.1111/obr.12949. Epub 2019 Nov 1. PMID: 31675146.
- Paixão C, Dias CM, Jorge R, Carraça EV, Yannakoulia M, de Zwaan M, Soini S, Hill JO, Teixeira PJ, Santos I. Successful weight loss maintenance: A systematic review of weight control registries. Obes Rev. 2020 May;21(5):e13003. doi: 10.1111/obr.13003. Epub 2020 Feb 12. PMID: 32048787.
- Pont SJ, Puhl R, Cook SR, Slusser W; SECTION ON OBESITY; OBESITY SOCIETY. Stigma Experienced by Children and Adolescents With Obesity. Pediatrics. 2017 Dec;140(6):e20173034. doi: 10.1542/peds.2017-3034. Epub 2017 Nov 20. PMID: 29158228.
- Puhl RM. What words should we use to talk about weight? A systematic review of quantitative and qualitative studies examining preferences for weight-related terminology. Obes Rev. 2020 Jun;21(6):e13008. doi: 10.1111/obr.13008. Epub 2020 Feb 12. PMID: 32048465.
- Qasim A, Turcotte M, de Souza RJ, Samaan MC, Champredon D, Dushoff J, Speakman JR, Meyre D. On the origin of obesity: identifying the biological, environmental and cultural drivers of genetic risk among human populations. Obes Rev. 2018 Feb;19(2):121-149. doi: 10.1111/obr.12625. Epub 2017 Nov 16. PMID: 29144594.
- Reddon H, Patel Y, Turcotte M, Pigeyre M, Meyre D. Revisiting the evolutionary origins of obesity: lazy versus peppy-thrifty genotype hypothesis. Obes Rev. 2018 Nov;19(11):1525-1543. doi: 10.1111/obr.12742. Epub 2018 Sep 27. PMID: 30261552.
- Rossi AP, Rubele S, Calugi S, Caliari C, Pedelini F, Soave F, Chignola E, Vittoria Bazzani P, Mazzali G, Dalle Grave R, Zamboni M. Weight Cycling as a Risk Factor for Low Muscle Mass and Strength in a Population of Males and Females with Obesity. Obesity (Silver Spring). 2019 Jul;27(7):1068-1075. doi: 10.1002/oby.22493. PMID: 31231958.
- Rubino F, Puhl RM, Cummings DE, Eckel RH, Ryan DH, Mechanick JI, Nadglowski J, Ramos Salas X, Schauer PR, Twenefour D, Apovian CM, Aronne LJ, Batterham RL, Berthoud HR, Boza C, Busetto L, Dicker D, De Groot M, Eisenberg D, Flint SW, Huang TT, Kaplan LM, Kirwan JP, Korner J, Kyle TK, Laferrère B, le Roux CW, McIver L, Mingrone G, Nece P, Reid TJ, Rogers AM, Rosenbaum M, Seeley RJ, Torres AJ, Dixon JB. Joint international consensus statement for ending stigma of obesity. Nat Med. 2020 Apr;26(4):485-497. doi: 10.1038/s41591-020-0803-x. Epub 2020 Mar 4. PMID: 32127716; PMCID: PMC7154011.
- Schrempft S, van Jaarsveld CHM, Fisher A, Herle M, Smith AD, Fildes A, Llewellyn CH. Variation in the Heritability of Child Body Mass Index by Obesogenic Home Environment. JAMA Pediatr. 2018 Dec 1;172(12):1153-1160. doi: 10.1001/jamapediatrics.2018.1508. PMID: 30285028; PMCID: PMC6396810.
- Schvey NA, Marwitz SE, Mi SJ, Galescu OA, Broadney MM, Young-Hyman D, Brady SM, Reynolds JC, Tanofsky-Kraff M, Yanovski SZ, Yanovski JA. Weight-based teasing is associated with gain in BMI and fat mass among children and adolescents at-risk for obesity: A longitudinal study. Pediatr Obes. 2019 Oct;14(10):e12538. doi: 10.1111/ijpo.12538. Epub 2019 May 29. PMID: 31144471; PMCID: PMC6728169.
- Tomiyama AJ. Stress and Obesity. Annu Rev Psychol. 2019 Jan 4;70:703-718. doi: 10.1146/annurev-psych-010418-102936. Epub 2018 Jun 21. PMID: 29927688.
- van der Heijden LB, Feskens EJM, Janse AJ. Maintenance interventions for overweight or obesity in children: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Obes Rev. 2018 Jun;19(6):798-809. doi: 10.1111/obr.12664. Epub 2018 Jan 23. PMID: 29363283.
- Vandevijvere S, Chow CC, Hall KD, Umali E, Swinburn BA. Increased food energy supply as a major driver of the obesity epidemic: a global analysis. Bull World Health Organ. 2015 Jul 1;93(7):446-56. doi: 10.2471/BLT.14.150565. PMID: 26170502; PMCID: PMC4490816.
- Veit R, Horstman LI, Hege MA, Heni M, Rogers PJ, Brunstrom JM, Fritsche A, Preissl H, Kullmann S. Health, pleasure, and fullness: changing mindset affects brain responses and portion size selection in adults with overweight and obesity. Int J Obes (Lond). 2020 Feb;44(2):428-437. doi: 10.1038/s41366-019-0400-6. Epub 2019 Jun 18. PMID: 31213656.
- Yokum S, Stice E. Weight gain is associated with changes in neural response to palatable food tastes varying in sugar and fat and palatable food images: a repeated-measures fMRI study. Am J Clin Nutr. 2019 Dec 1;110(6):1275-1286. doi: 10.1093/ajcn/nqz204. PMID: 31535135; PMCID: PMC6885480.